CharlestonRanked
Antonio's Pizzeria
75 restaurants

Antonio's Pizzeria

Ranked № 75 restaurant in Charleston, SC · 8636 Dorchester Rd, North Charleston

No-frills North Charleston pizza counter on Dorchester Road, drawing steady locals since the neighborhood long predates the city's restaurant boom.

Community rating
4.7
Based on 703 ratings
92 locals voted4.7 on Google
Beloved
Rate it
4.8 · 92
Word on the street

What locals are saying

Antonio's Pizzeria on Dorchester Road has quickly built a strong local reputation as the go-to spot for authentic New York-style thin-crust pizza in the North Charleston area, drawing particular praise from transplants with NY/NJ roots who say it legitimately holds up to the real thing. The stripped-down setup — minimal seating, carry-out focused — is consistently noted but rarely a dealbreaker, as regulars treat it as a neighborhood slice shop rather than a sit-down destination. A minority of reviewers temper expectations, calling it solid but average NY pizza rather than exceptional.

best NY-style pizza in the Charleston areathin crust done rightcarry-out / minimal seatingendorsed by NY/NJ transplantsneighborhood gem, not hypesome find it average rather than exceptional
In the feed

On socials

Posts and write-ups zeroing in on the NY-style thin crust as the single draw — creators and commenters (especially self-identified NY/NJ transplants) call it 'the best NY-style pizza in the Charleston area' and praise the classic pepperoni slice and plain cheese pie as proof of authenticity. The streamlined menu (cheese and pepperoni only) is framed as a quality signal, not a limitation. Dedicated TikTok/Reels creator content is sparse — most social chatter surfaces through food-blog write-ups and Facebook/Roadtrippers comments rather than Reels or TikTok videos.

NY/NJ transplants calling it 'the real thing'pepperoni slice and classic cheese as the must-ordersfocused two-item menu praised as an authenticity badge'Trust the Crust' community program earns goodwill mentionsa minority voice calls it 'pretty average NY pizza'
The fit

Who it’s for & what you get

What you get
Sourced from Google · confirm with the venue
Food & drink
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
Service
  • Dine-in
  • Takeout
  • Delivery
Atmosphere
  • Kid-friendly
Practical
  • Wheelchair accessible
  • Restroom
  • Free parking
Common questions

Frequently asked

Is Antonio's Pizzeria one of the best restaurants in Charleston?

Antonio's Pizzeria is ranked #75 restaurant in Charleston by community votes.

What is Antonio's Pizzeria best known for?

No-frills North Charleston pizza counter on Dorchester Road, drawing steady locals since the neighborhood long predates the city's restaurant boom.

Who should go to Antonio's Pizzeria?

Antonio's Pizzeria works well for both locals and visitors looking for a quality restaurant in Charleston.

Where is Antonio's Pizzeria located?

Antonio's Pizzeria is located at 8636 Dorchester Rd, North Charleston, Charleston, SC.

Local takes

Join the conversation

0 comments

Have a take?

Sign in to share what you really think.

  1. No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.
Updated daily by community votesLast revised May 4, 2026
If you like Antonio's Pizzeria

Similar restaurants in Charleston

See the full ranking
Pizza a Modo Mio (New York Pizzeria)

Pizza a Modo Mio (New York Pizzeria)

3125 Bees Ferry Rd, Charleston

New York-style pizza shop on Bees Ferry Road, slinging pies by the slice alongside bagels out of a strip mall.

4.7 · 85
Loved
4.6649 ratings
Read
Boxcar Betty's

Boxcar Betty's

7800 Rivers Ave Suite 1090, North Charleston
4.6 · 114
Loved
4.4874 ratings
Read
843 Korean BBQ & Sushi House

843 Korean BBQ & Sushi House

6601 Rivers Ave, North Charleston

Casual eatery offering BBQ beef, pork & veggies cooked on tabletop grills, plus sushi.

4.4 · 250
Loved
4.42.4k ratings
Read
Belle Station Sports Bar & Grill

Belle Station Sports Bar & Grill

545 Belle Station Blvd, Mt Pleasant

Neighborhood sports bar off Highway 17 with pizza, sandwiches, and dog-friendly patio in the Belle Hall corridor.

4.4 · 39
Liked
4.2302 ratings
Read
Around the corner

Nearby in Hanahan

Toro Birria
Restaurants

Toro Birria

8440 Dorchester Rd ste 1, North Charleston

Birria-focused Mexican counter on Dorchester Road serving consommé-dipped tacos with beer and wine in North Charleston.

4.8 · 18
Loved
4.6140 ratings
Read
0.8 mi