Word on the street
What locals are saying
A few doors from Shem Creek, Benny Palmetto's operates on a single premise: the 28-inch New York-style pie — the only size on the menu — sold by the enormous, fold-required slice or stacked whole for a crowd. Dough is made fresh daily in an open kitchen, the garlic mushroom and pepperoni slices draw the most loyalty, and the price ceiling sits around five bucks a slice. Service swings between genuinely warm and visibly checked-out, and the 2 a.m. weekend close time makes clear exactly what kind of place this is.
28 inches is the only size — that's the whole pointgarlic mushroom slice earns repeat visitsfresh dough, open kitchenlate-night Shem Creek anchorPBR-and-a-slice pricingservice inconsistency is the recurring friction
The fit
Who it’s for & what you get
What you get
Sourced from Google · confirm with the venue
