What locals are saying
Melvin's on James Island is a genuine Charleston institution — a Bessinger family recipe dating to 1939 — that won back serious local credibility after owner David Bessinger ditched gas-assisted smokers and returned to offset wood burning in 2015. The pulled pork and smoked turkey earn consistent praise, and the iconic mustard-based Golden Secret sauce is considered a must, but the hash and slaw draw repeated criticism for being thin and runny; pricing also draws grumbling, with some locals calling it steep for a counter-service format. Long-time residents carry childhood nostalgia for the place, while newer critics see it as a solid but uneven neighborhood BBQ spot rather than a destination.
On socials
TikTok creators and food bloggers consistently call Melvin's 'Charleston BBQ dreams' — every post leads with the Golden Secret mustard-based sauce as the defining thing to try, followed by hard praise for the pulled pork, fall-off-the-bone spare ribs, and smoked wings. Creators tell followers to go all-in: ribs, pulled pork, mac & cheese, hush puppies, and cornbread, calling 'every single bite unreal.' The jalapeño cheeseburger and country BBQ hash with rice also get shoutouts. The sauce bar is consistently flagged as a must-stop moment.
Who it’s for & what you get
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Dessert
- Coffee
- Beer
- Kids menu
- Dine-in
- Takeout
- Delivery
- Outdoor seating
- Good for groups
- Kid-friendly
- Wheelchair accessible
- Restroom
- Free parking
Frequently asked
Is Melvin's BBQ - James Island one of the best restaurants in Charleston?
Melvin's BBQ - James Island is ranked #417 restaurant in Charleston by community votes.
What is Melvin's BBQ - James Island best known for?
Family-friendly BBQ eatery serving ribs & other Southern dishes in casual, woodsy surrounds.
Who should go to Melvin's BBQ - James Island?
Melvin's BBQ - James Island works well for both locals and visitors looking for a quality restaurant in Charleston.
Where is Melvin's BBQ - James Island located?
Melvin's BBQ - James Island is located at 538 Folly Rd, Charleston, Charleston, SC.
Join the conversation
Have a take?
Sign in to share what you really think.
- No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.
Similar restaurants in Charleston
The Harlow
Neighborhood coffee shop and gathering spot on James Island's Harbor View Road, with live music and a dog-friendly patio.
Ellis Creek Fish Camp
Visitors can eat indoors or on the terrace with countryside views at this casual seafood option.
The Great Greek Mediterranean Grill - Charleston, SC
Fast-casual Greek chain outpost on Folly Road serving gyros, bowls, and baklava in a strip mall off James Island.
Bohemian Bull
Upscale bar food, including brisket burgers, join craft beer & bourbon in a funky, plank-walled pub.
Nearby in James Island
Point Break Coffee & Drive Thru
Drive-thru coffee and acai spot on Folly Road, with dog-friendly seating and occasional live music.
Magic Nails
Strip-mall nail salon on Folly Road, steady neighborhood spot for manicures and pedicures near the Crosstown.
Just You Fitness
Private personal training studio on Folly Road, built for one-on-one sessions away from crowded gym floors.
Bagel Nation
Casual eatery that offers multiple varieties of bagels to go as well as stacked bagel sandwiches.
Tea Flower Skincare
Folly Road skincare studio specializing in tea-based facial treatments and massage, tucked into a quiet strip near James Island.
